I absolutely love how smart this book is, and how it allows for elementary aged readers to feel that “aha moment” when they read it, get it, and realize that they need to remember the lessons because it could happen to them. The illustrations are an added bonus and are perfectly aligned with the tone and text of the story. My only issue, is the title. Pitches reads as a euphemism for another word and since the book involves girl drama, teasing, and misunderstandings, it really is hard to not have that thought zap your brain when you see the title. Perhaps if the “and Other Problems” would have used a bigger font on the word “Problems” the alliteration would have been more obvious, and hidden the word “Pitches” a bit. If I’m alone in this, I apologize to the author and publisher, (I’ve mentioned my concern to them), but for others that saw the word and questioned the content, rest assured it is about baseball and the book doesn’t have even a speck of questionable content.
Amira is at a new school, and luckily it is Tuesday, Pizza Tuesday to be exact, and she can’t wait to dive into a cheesy slice. Unfortunately, Olivia takes the last cheese piece and when Amira asks if she will let her have it, Olivia says she had it first. Stuck with an egg salad sandwich that smells, Amira sits alone and broods.
In gym they are playing baseball, but no one knows how good Amira is, and she is picked last. When Amira is up to bat, Olivia is the pitcher and her pitches are terrible. Amira still mad about lunch and afraid that the others will blame her for not hitting the unhitable balls, shouts, “you’re supposed to aim at my bat.” Everyone laughs, but Olivia runs off clearly upset. The new pitcher sends a decent throw and Amira hits a home run. The captain of the team praises her, and Amira is hopeful she’ll have someone to sit with her at lunch. After class, Amira sees Olivia crying in the bathroom and no one asking her if she is ok, Amira doesn’t feel so well, and doesn’t ask either. On the bus ride home Amira is greeted with cheers for her home run, but Elena the captain, isn’t among them.
The next day is picture day, and Amira trips and rips her shirt. Everyone laughs, Elena says, “it was an ugly shirt anyways.” Only one person offers her help. Could Amira have misread the whole class dynamics? How should she move forward?
Sorry, I’m not going to spoil the ending, but the message about owning up to your choices is stressed, along with making kind decisions, and sometimes needing to take a step back and understand things from someone else’s perspective.
Like nearly all Ruqaya’s Bookshelf books, the story is universal, but the characters, illustrations, and point of view is a relatable Muslim one that allows our young Muslim readers to feel seen and celebrated. The reliable large glossy pages make the book a great deal for your money and is available on the publisher’s website: http://www.ruqayasbookshelf or from my favorite bookstore http://www.crescentmoonstore.com
Islamic School Librarian 