WHY I LOVE IT:
The framing story is so seamless and so masterfully done, that I would love to interrogate Intisar Khanani and Nafiza Asad and unearth how they made this magic happen. From child trafficking to resistance soldiers, Bedouin tribes to found family, the format is not just a loose thread of the Arabian Nights, the words between the covers are Shehrazade’s weaving’s fleshed out and expertly spun.
The framing story is so seamless and so masterfully done, that I would love to interrogate Intisar Khanani and Nafiza Asad and unearth how they made this magic happen. From child trafficking to resistance soldiers, Bedouin tribes to found family, the format is not just a loose thread of the Arabian Nights, the words between the covers are Shehrazade’s weaving’s fleshed out and expertly spun.
The timeliness and commentary on refugees often feels Palestinian coded which makes the collection hit harder, and a few by Palestinian authors are unapologetically about the nakba and genocide. The stories never overly explained for an outside gaze, and the impact they have on the children never left to exist only on the surface. Who the four meet, who shares the story, what they have overcome or are about to face, the emotions that are consuming them, all feel intentional and relatable.
And the Islam, subhanAllah, it isn’t a check mark, it is so present and so intuitive to who the characters are, their actions, their awareness of Allah swt, their purpose in this world, and their lens to the injustices they endure and face.
FLAGS:
Death, loss, killing, occupation, magic, relations, rape, drugs, some cursing, theft, child trafficking….etc.. The book is YA and pretty halal, the above mentioned are not anything I would worry a teenager reading. My 11 year old was in the car while I was listening at times and I didn’t find anything awkward or inappropriate.
TOOLS FOR LEADING THE DISCUSSION:
Yes yes yes. This book needs to be discussed and taught and enjoyed with others. The last story is such a masterclass worthy of discussion and needs to be contemplated and examined, but I think in isolation it isn’t where all the weight comes from, it is from the build up to it, that makes it worth sitting with and contemplating and then discussing. There is no happily ever after, this book is too real for that, and the points brought up work on so many layers for the story it exists in, the larger story in the book, and for the readers in their own lives.
Yes yes yes. This book needs to be discussed and taught and enjoyed with others. The last story is such a masterclass worthy of discussion and needs to be contemplated and examined, but I think in isolation it isn’t where all the weight comes from, it is from the build up to it, that makes it worth sitting with and contemplating and then discussing. There is no happily ever after, this book is too real for that, and the points brought up work on so many layers for the story it exists in, the larger story in the book, and for the readers in their own lives.



