NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! Seriously, astagfiraAllah! This 24 page middle grades non fiction book about Islam and Eid published in 2018 with smart-board connections and QR scan media enhancements on its surface would seem to be a great classroom all-in-one to learn about the basics of celebrations, Islam, Ramadan, and Eid. BUT, NO! The information is all sorts of off, and there is an illustration depicting Prophet Muhammad (saw). How is this sort of ignorance even possible? This isn’t even a Karen Katz My First Ramadan depiction where you can possibly argue and stretch that it isn’t a depiction of the Prophet, but just of the people. Every picture in the book is a photograph, except on the page talking about the first revelation, it is an illustration and there are no other people on the page, just a picture of the Quran. I encourage you all to see if your public library shelves the book and ask them to pull it. ****UPDATE: My library pulled it, and the publisher has halted sales of it. Alhumdulillah! We must remember we can use our voices to make a differences, that people are receptive and willing, not always, but we won’t know unless we try. ****
The book covers nine topics on two page spreads ranging from the generic what is a festival, to what is Islam to prayer and worship and festival food. The book has a little girl Noor that pops up on pages to tell you how to say a word and has a glossary with her definitions at the end. Even the definitions at the end about the foods are wrong, they seem to have switched ma’amoul and sheer khurma. To it’s credit the book has a photographs of a lot of diverse Muslims celebrating Ramadan and Eid, unfortunately so much is wrong, from little things saying that “Sheer Khurma is traditionally eaten for breakfast during Eid,” to “Muhammad spread Allah’s words to other people by writing them down in a holy book…”.
It has in quotes that a voice from the sky called to Muahmmad, “You have been chosen to hear Allah’s words.” This quote and its source are nor footnoted or referenced, clearly they are not from surah Al Alaq. I’m not sure where they are getting this from. There are no salutaions after Rasulallah’s name nor is Prophet before it.
Other informative sentences are vague and suggest misinformation. It says that we believe in Allah and pray to him in a mosque, which yes is fine, but we also pray to him in other places five times a day and the way it is worded, I don’t think that would be understood. I feel like the role of the imam is also overly elevated in the book. The takeaway I assume would be that only an Imam can lead a prayer and we must always pray in a mosque.
Ultimately the biggest problem I have in the book is the depiction of our beloved Prophet. I can forgive that they assume eating a random dish for Eid is religious and not just cultural, but I can’t forgive such basic ignorance in a book that presumably is trying to teach about a faith to reduce ignorance and misunderstandings.